[ Home | Staff & Contacts | HiFi Playground | Listening tests | DIY & Tweakings | Music & Books ]
Product: Teac CD-P 1100
- CD player
Manufacturer: Teac
- Japan
Approx. price: 150 Euro/US $
Reviewer: Lucio
Cadeddu
Who said that the HiFi
gear should be expen$ive?
We believe that the HiFi, as a means to
bring Music to the people, should be affordable for everyone, so that
everyone can enjoy the joys :-) of Music.
So you wanted a cheap CD
player. Here it is: the Teac CD-P1100, an incredibly cheap player
that for less than 200$ (list price in Italy, your mileage may vary)
gives you a complete remote control, a centrally placed transport and
a sound quality that I'm going to tell you in a few lines.
Teac is a well known
brand in the HiFi world and especially renowed for making some pretty
good sounding CD players and excellent transports (the VRDS series)
used by some Hi-end firms as transports for their hi-zoot
no-compromise CD players.
I was wondering if such a know-how could
affect in some way the low -end of the catalogue of the Japanese
firm, without using stiff and heavy aluminium cabinets, esoteric
transports and the like.
The Teac CD-P1100 gives you everything
you need: a solidly-built cabinet, a central transport, an
user-friendly remote control, a phones output with volume control and
a pletora of functions (intro check, shuffle play, programmable
sequences and so on) that the standard audiophile uses maybe once in
a lifetime :-)
It is a 1-bit machine with a double-resolution
digital filter and a triple laser beam.
A look at the inside
reveals a well-designed layout, all the cables are glued to the
chassis and the power transformer is solidly placed far away from the
mainboard, at the bottom of the cabinet.
The power cable isn't
detachable but the RCA output jacks are spaced enough to allow you to
use even special cables with oversized connectors.
The top cover
is secured to the chassis by means of 5 screws, instead of the usual
4, so that the whole player seems solid and non-resonant. Could we
ask for more?
Let's play Music now!
I've tested this
player both on my reference big system into my large living-room and
in my second system, a budget-conscious chain into a small room where
a cheap player like the CD-P1100 should feel at home :-)
I've used
several interconnects to test this player, among these there were: a
cheap Monster Interlink 200, an Interlink 400 mkII and a DIY cable.
OK, it is a bit hard
to talk about tonal balance for a CD player that costs less
tha a medium priced interconnect cable...anyway:
the sound of this
CD player is warm with a gentle roll-off on the highs.
If you were
thinking it sounded tizzy and harsh well, think again.
The high
range of this player is a little bit on the tame side, cymbals and
high-frequency percussions are less lively than one could expect from
a budget player.
The medium range is sometimes a little bit too
forward instead, giving to the reproduction a strange effect
of *presence* which seems a bit excessive, especially because it is
not mated with a brilliant high range.
Despite of this tonal
balance the voices are beautifully reproduced, clear and
well-defined, not always amazing but still convincing and somewhat
realistic.
From time to time a harsh note can be heard but it is
negligible and easily forgiven, if one considers the price range.
The
bass range is good, decently extended and powerful, though it lacks
the impact and the extension of the best budget players around (which
cost two or three times the CD-P1100, though).
Sometimes it lacks
some control and you have the feeling as the bass goes here and there
in your listening room, wandering aimlessly :-)
Much of this
depends on the kind of table you have and on the kind of feet you use
under the CD-P1100. Tip Toes or similar devices can make a huge
difference. But we'll talk about this later.
So, long story short,
the tonal balance of this player can be summarized as follows: bass
and mid range a little bit *forward* with a gentle roll-off on the
highs. A reason for this behaviour can be found in the dynamic
performance of this player:
Cheap CD players are
easily recognizable because of their poor dynamics, this fault being
mainly due to the cheap output analogue stages.
The Teac CD-P1100
is by no means different and its sound is slow, sometimes lifeless as
it comes out from a cheap cassette deck.
Well, not exactly. It
gives this impression when compared to faster players, while listened
*all alone* its sound is enjoyable and it reminds the feeling of some
old-style tube amplifiers.
For example the explosions of the Jim
Keltner's drum kit (of the ubiquitous Sheffield Drum Record :-) ) are
less impressive and dynamic than usual but this player is capable to
*resize* each dynamic jump coherently...everything is reproduced as
it was in a reduced scale but no preferences are given to some
portion of the audio spectrum.
So overall dynamics is good both in
the bass and in the mid range and control is always precise, a rare
virtue for ANY CD player.
For example it doesn't scream or
compress the sound when the musical programs becomes complex (for
example: with a big choir or a huge pipe organ). And this is quite
incredible for such a cheap player.
Microdynamics is good, this
player can follow each small variation with a fair sense of pace and
timing, it is not fast but still coherent and enjoyable.
For
example the piano is slower than usual and it seems it has been
recorded in a wider room, with the mikes far away from it.
Hence
attacks and staccato's are less impressive and while the right hand
part of the keyboard is still realistic, the left hand is sometimes
confused.
When used into the small system of the smaller listening
room, the little CD player can take its revenge and its sound becomes
crisper and plenty of impact. Clearly its sonic personality feels
more *at home* with budget-oriented systems and small rooms where the
sometimes a slow and lazy sound is mostly welcomed by aggressive
little speakers and rooms.
Large rooms need impact, power and
speed...otherwise the sound becomes too *relaxed* and little
involving.
So the Teac, when mated with good little amplifiers
(Rotel, NAD, AMC, Arcam...), inside a small room can be a clever
choice for the audiophile on a limited budget.
If dynamics is a major
drawback with cheap CD players, 3D imaging is a plain nightmare for
them.
Image width, height and depth are just fair and everything
appears smaller than usual. Conversely, the focus and the precision
of the image is good, better than expected.
The center of the
image and the contour of the singers is precise and realistic, it
never fluctuates from left to right or back and forth, giving the
idea of a small but rock-solid 3D imaging.
The depth of the image
can be improved by using different feet under the CD player but we'll
leave these tweaks to a separate article, when we'll introduce you
our cool Teac CD-P1100 TLE (TNT
Limited Edition). The height of the image seems normal with
standard commercial recordings, for example the height of the singers
seems natural.
With some audiophile recordings, where the height
of the virtual image can easily reach the ceiling (and above) of your
listening room, the CD-P1100 resizes everything so that, for example,
the pipes of the organ in the Cantate Domino (Proprius) are shorter
than I am used to *see*...:-)
The Teac CD-P1100
isn't very sensitive to warm-in: it sounds more or less the same even
after a few hours. It is ready to give the 90-95% of its performance,
thumbs up for this.
Conversely it is very sensitive to placement:
rubber feet, spikes and similar devices can make a dramatic
difference. I recommend you to take a look at the tweaked version:
Teac CD-P1100 TLE.
As for
cables: it is very difficult to find an interconnect that is
reasonably and proportionally priced. You can try with the Monster
Interlink 200, for example, or with some of our DIY
projects.
Of course the more you spend the better it gets but
one should remain *realistic*: this player costs less than 200 US $
(150 $ is more realistic) and it would be ridiculous to use a 200 $
cable with it.
Now the question is:
are 150 $ enough for a decently sounding CD player? Well, I'd say yes
but I'd prefer to answer *it depends*.
It depends on what do you
expect from your HiFi system. If you're planning to save as much as
possible but still don't want to buy a compact mini-system then you
should take into serious consideration this low-cost CD player: it is
solidly built by a renowed and respectable HiFi firm, it is heavily
upgradable and sounds pretty well for the money.
Also, if you're
still using a portable CD player (thumbs down) to listen to your CDs,
open your windows wide and throw it away...this Teac CD-P1100 will
beat your portable in every aspect: sound, ease to use and
durability.
If you're planning to test your tweaking skills on a
CD-player this is the player of choice, definitely.
Affordable HiFi? Definitely yes. Will it replace your Marantz CD 67 or your Arcam Alpha? Definitely not. But do you still believe in miracles, then? :-)
Copyright © 1998 Lucio Cadeddu
[ Home | Staff & Contacts | HiFi Playground | Listening tests | DIY & Tweakings | Music & Books ]